The Sierra Club

Home

About

Calendar

Getting involved

Local Issues & Other Resources

Contact Us

Pickerel Lake Preservation Succeeds!

DNR Leadership accepts essential points of
Friends of Pickerel Lake (FPL) Position.

Written by Linda Berauer

Our last Pickerel Lake update brought the news of the DNR Director's order to prohibit the launching of gas-powered motorboats from the lake access site. The DNR leadership confirmed, in the end, that they accept most of the other points that we have all been fighting for.

EVERYONE who wrote a letter, sent an e-mail, signed a petition, went to the public meeting in Pinckney, made a donation, provided information, offered their technical expertise, skill, and advice, lobbied their local officials, offered moral support, spread the word among friends and neighbors, and helped in countless other ways deserves enormous credit for turning the DNR juggernaut around on this issue. This would NEVER have happened without all supporters staying actively engaged and determined to stick with a vision of Pickerel Lake as a place for quiet, non-motorized recreation at one of the few remaining pristine lakes in our little corner of Michigan.

New plan highlights:

  • Beach and access alley will remain sandy - No concrete or gravel will be laid at the shoreline or down the sandy alley leading from the parking area to the shore.
  • No vehicular access to shore - Large boulders will be placed at the top of the sandy alley to ensure that no vehicles are able to drive down to the shore. Boats must be carry-down only.
  • Gravel parking area - The DNR has agreed to stabilize the parking area with gravel, rather than concrete or asphalt. Many of us would have preferred the surface to remain sandy, but the DNR remained firm on the issue of hardening the surface to prevent further deterioration due to motorized traffic. Large boulders will also be placed around the perimeter of the parking area to prevent vehicular encroachment of the sandy bank surrounding the parking area. The boulders, along with erosion mats and native plantings, will help to prevent erosion and thus protect the surrounding woods.
  • Adequate parking spaces - This was a very tough issue and the core group fought on this to the end. The DNR's original plan was to drastically limit parking to 8 spaces -- including four double-length spaces for vehicles pulling trailers, in line with their plan for a concrete boat ramp. After prolonged insistence that this was a bottom-line issue for us, they began saying they might consider 12 spaces, and now they have agreed to 21 spaces. One parking space will be designated for handicap use. The design team also initially planned to put concrete separators between each space to prevent over-parking, but after some pushing they agreed to drop that element of their new plan.
  • Access road - The road from Hankerd to the parking area will be graded.

Some unexpected changes:

  • Boardwalk - The new plan includes a boardwalk leading from the parking area to the shoreline for handicap access to the beach. The boardwalk will stay fairly close to the eastern edge of the alley, and will be at ground level, with no handrails, to minimize visual impact while ensuring safety for wheelchair users. ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) regulations specify that when a public facility is altered to a certain degree, accessibility for wheel chair users must be considered. A representative sample of different types of natural and recreational public sites must be wheelchair accessible. In this case, the DNR has determined that Pickerel Lake should be wheelchair-accessible, since its unmarred beauty is unique in the area. We are happy that the final design of the boardwalk will be visually unimposing and will not obstruct others from sitting in the sandy alley.
  • Pier - We were stunned to learn that the pier will be removed. The DNR Risk Management Team has decided that the pier is a risk liability. Neither the Parks and Recreation Division nor the Fisheries Division has the funds available to bring it up to safety standards, so they have decided to remove it. The pier was never a subject in our discussions with the DNR or in any of the letters that FPL members shared with us. We learned about the pier removal decision just days before work on the site began, directly from the Resource Management Deputy, who himself had just learned of this decision from the Risk Management Team. We know that many people will miss the pier, which had become a focal point for sunbathers as well as anglers.

Timeline

The DNR began work at the site in early May, with the intent to complete it and have the site open by Memorial Day.

As of early July, the access road has been graded; the parking area has been graded, resurfaced with pervious gravel and reconfigured into a circular design with space for approximately 21 cars, including one handicap-accessible space; grass has been planted in the center and around the parking areas; small boulders have been installed around the parking area and at the neck of the sandy alley to prevent drive-down access to the shore.

An ironic twist has delayed opening of the access road. As the work was nearing completion, the Road Commission issued a stop work order to the DNR due to the limited line-of-sight distance as one approaches the access road from Hankerd Road. The DNR is currently working with its engineers to draw up a plan for the entrance that would qualify for a variance from the Road Commission. At this point there is no estimated time for opening the access road. Visitors can park at nearby Half-Moon Lake or Silver Lake and hike in to Pickerel Lake. The trail connecting Silver Lake with Pickerel is a pleasant, twenty minutes walk.

Conclusion

The contrast between the DNR's original plan for Pickerel Lake and the current plan is stark. After more than two years of hard work and persistence on everyone's part, the plan for the lake is completely reversed - from a concrete boat launch ramp, gravel all the way down to the ramp, and a severely limited parking lot with only 8 spaces favoring vehicles carrying boat trailers - to a plan which retains the essentials of what we love about Pickerel Lake - a sandy beach, waters clear of spillage from gas motors, a quiet, safe place to swim and just sit and enjoy the beauty of one of the last undeveloped lakes in our area.

We will continue to work towards getting a complete No Gas Motors ordinance passed for Pickerel Lake, so that motorboats will not be able to enter Pickerel Lake from the channel from Crooked Lake.

We will continue to send out updates to everyone on our e-mail list, and will continue to work to ensure that important details of what we have asked for, such as minimal visually disturbing signage and as much parking as possible within the current footprint of the parking area, is accepted and implemented. To receive future updates by e-mail, or to send us your comments, send an e-mail to friendsofpickerellake@hotmail.com. Our website address is www.friendsofpickerellake.org/.

Back to the Sierra Club - Huron Valley Group Home Page
Back to the Archive index

Last updated by Suzanne Brucker Heiney, August 2003.